Contact Us for a Free Consultation (662) 563-4613

Blog

Mississippi Supreme Court Rules in Nationally-Watched Anti-Concurrent Cause Case

Posted by Paul R. Scott | Jan 04, 2018 | 0 Comments

Mississippi supreme court rules

Corban v. USAA, a unanimous opinion by the Mississippi Supreme Court, clears up a question of tremendous importance to homeowners across the country.

The Corban case has been watched by courts and legal scholars throughout the nation. The Mississippi Supreme Court rejected the Fifth Circuit “Erie guesses” of the Tuepker and Leonard opinions regarding the Anti-Concurrent Cause (ACC) clause.  The ACC clause does not relieve an insurance company of its obligation to establish causation if it seeks to exclude coverage for part of the loss caused by water.

The opinion says homeowners “all risk” policies mean exactly what policyholders across the Gulf Coast, as well as legal scholars across the country, have said from day one: (1) Concurrent means concurrent, i.e. at the same time, and (2) In “all risk” policies like those sold today, it is the insurance company's burden to prove what part of the loss was caused by an excluded peril (water in the case of a hurricane).  The Corban opinion is of tremendous importance to victims of future disasters both in Mississippi and throughout the nation.

See Full Opinion:

http://www.mssc.state.ms.us/Images/Opinions/CO58302.pdf

About the Author

Comments

There are no comments for this post. Be the first and Add your Comment below.

Leave a Comment

Contact Us Today

For most legal matters, the most important element is time. Contact us today at our Batesville, Mississippi office at (662) 563-4613, or our Hernando, Mississippi office at (662) 429-5041.

Menu